October 27, 2006
MORE MILLS MYSTERY
Analysis of:
Gazit Snaps Up Mills Shares | www.retailtrafficmag.com
This analysis is solely the work of the author. It has not been edited or endorsed by GLG.
Implications: Gazit-Globe, an Israeli real estate investment firm controlled by Mr. Chaim Katzman (the outgoing CEO of the Equity One REIT), has acquired 9% of the Mills stock. He has also offered to invest an additional $1.2 billion to recapitalize the company.
Although the entire transaction raises more questions than answers, it has again forced Mills back into the spotlight at a critical point in their efforts to both satisfy the SEC and New York Stock Exchange.
Analysis: To most observers who have been following the Mills saga, this latest twist is but a speed bump. My opinion is that Mr. Katzman is not smarter than some of the best and brightest of the CEO's of United States REITs. What ever his game plan might be, it will not be as successful as the plans already in place by those prospective bidders who completed their due diligence some months ago and decided not to bid.
The Mills portfolio has not improved since the final bid date. Several of the previously announced deals that supposedly would "save" Mills have not materialized. Some of the deals -in -progress have been adversely impacted by events beyond their control (i.e. Block 37 on Chicago's State Street has serious new competition as the result of Carson's being converted to a new retail complex), and several of Mills' key employees have jumped ship.
Over the years I have seen instances of foreign investors inserting themselves into our industry and in effect saying "I can do better than the best minds in the American real estate industry". Not one has turned out to be correct. In fact, the only one who has proven to be successful is Westfield. They are the only one who has had the patience to hire top people from our industry and gradually build a business based solely on well established principals developed in this country over years of trial and error.
Although the entire transaction raises more questions than answers, it has again forced Mills back into the spotlight at a critical point in their efforts to both satisfy the SEC and New York Stock Exchange.
Analysis: To most observers who have been following the Mills saga, this latest twist is but a speed bump. My opinion is that Mr. Katzman is not smarter than some of the best and brightest of the CEO's of United States REITs. What ever his game plan might be, it will not be as successful as the plans already in place by those prospective bidders who completed their due diligence some months ago and decided not to bid.
The Mills portfolio has not improved since the final bid date. Several of the previously announced deals that supposedly would "save" Mills have not materialized. Some of the deals -in -progress have been adversely impacted by events beyond their control (i.e. Block 37 on Chicago's State Street has serious new competition as the result of Carson's being converted to a new retail complex), and several of Mills' key employees have jumped ship.
Over the years I have seen instances of foreign investors inserting themselves into our industry and in effect saying "I can do better than the best minds in the American real estate industry". Not one has turned out to be correct. In fact, the only one who has proven to be successful is Westfield. They are the only one who has had the patience to hire top people from our industry and gradually build a business based solely on well established principals developed in this country over years of trial and error.
Report a Concern
More GLG News in
Real Estate
Most Popular:
Source Article | Expert Analyses
Market Report: Sunshine State?
www.multihousingnews.com
July Existing-Home Sales Show Gain
www.realtor.org
Some Fear Commercial Property Loans Will Be Next Stage in Downturn
www.nytimes.com
SIOR Commercial Real Estate Index Reflects Country's Economic Woes
www.prnewswire.com
Real Estate Investors Invade California
www.marketwatch.com
Fasten your seatbelts ‘cause its going to be a very bumpy ride!...But we already knew that, didn’t we?
September 1, 2008
Far Too Optimistic View From Florida's Housing "Experts(?)"
September 1, 2008
When data is vague or inconclusive, look at the real world
August 28, 2008
The other side of the coin
August 28, 2008
FINANCIALS SHOT IN THE FOOT
August 26, 2008

